WATERTOWN, N.Y. — The latest property transactions in the city of Watertown filed at the Jefferson County clerk’s office in May 2024:
Looking to buy or sell property in Jefferson County?
127 S. Pearl Avenue
Seller: Jose Dolores Lemus III and Myra Bolanos, Fresno, CA
Buyer: Shawn House and Cara Ramsaran, 917 Riggs Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2012 for $126,000
City’s Total Assessment: $103,700
Price: $156,700 Filed: May 30
1348 Sunset Ridge
Seller: Nicholas Turnbull and Andie Pipher, 1348 Sunset Ridge, Watertown
Buyer: Antonio and Brenda Lettera, 1348 Sunset Ridge, Watertown
Property: built in 1957, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in June 2022 for $471,700
City’s Total Assessment: $391,500
Price: $510,000 Filed: May 30
Prepared by:
412 S. Hamilton Street
Seller: George Briggs, 19162 Woodside Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Andre A. Venzen, Converse, TN
Property: built in 1926, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in May 2023 for $75,000
City’s Total Assessment: $124,700
Price: $210,000 Filed: May 30
163 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Cheryl A. Evans, 163 Flower Ave. E., Watertown
Buyer: Lance and Cheryl A. Evans, 163 Flower Ave. E., Watertown
Property: built in 1909, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2010 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $121,300
Price: $0 Filed: May 29
Prepared by:
136 Duffy Street
Seller: Mark Condit administrator of Samantha L. Condit Estate
Buyer: Mark Condit, 136 Duffy St., Watertown
Property: built in 1929, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 1999 for $56,000
City’s Total Assessment: $93,100
Price: $0 Filed: May 29
Prepared by:
130 Colorado Avenue
Seller: Christian P. Hickey, 130 Colorado Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Christian P. Hickey and Megan Hickey, 130 Colorado Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2012 for $77,000
City’s Total Assessment: $98,400
Price: $0 Filed: May 28
817 Sherman Street
Seller: Sherry Goodfriend, executor of Sally Goodfriend Estate
Buyer: Sherry and Deanna Goodfriend, 817 Sherman St., Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $81,000
Price: $0 Filed: May 28
Prepared by:
409 E. Hoard Street
Seller: Karen L. Parks, 409 E. Hoard St., Watertown
Buyer: John R. Parks, Clay, NY, and Allison L. Parks, Clinton, MA
Property: built in 1915, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $90,900
Price: $0 Filed: May 24
126 N. Orchard Street
Seller: Nuno B. Henriques and Celia M. Henriques, Union, NJ
Buyer: Monument Property Group, LLC, 339 Dodge Ave., Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1881, sold in Oct. 2010 for $105,000
City’s Total Assessment: $87,700
Price: $110,000 Filed: May 24
812 Rutland Place
Seller: Daniel S. Tibbles, 664 Emerson St., Watertown
Buyer: Sonja J. Tibbles, 812 Rutland Place, Watertown
Property: built in 1922, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $35,700
Price: $0 Filed: May 24
817 Bigham Avenue
Seller: Daniel S. Tibbles, 664 Emerson St., Watertown
Buyer: Richard A. Tibbles, 414 S. Massey St., Apt. 1, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 5 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 1996 for $10,000
City’s Total Assessment: $26,400
Price: $0 Filed: May 24
519 Pearl Street
Seller: Bret Walker, PO Box 246, Dexter, NY
Buyer: Elienne Paulemon, 26351 Falcon Lane, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in April 2019 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $46,200
Price: $152,500 Filed: May 24
657 Olive Street
Seller: Jose Marrero, APO, AE
Buyer: North Star Rentals NNY, LLC, 1634 State St., Watertown
Property: built in 1950, sold in Nov. 2017 for $120,000
City’s Total Assessment: $111,200
Price: $130,000 Filed: May 22
279 S. Ontario Drive
Seller: Song Zhu and Li Zhao Zhu, 279 S. Ontario Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Song Zhu, 279 S. Ontario St., Watertown
Property: built in 1963, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in July 2007 for $200,000
City’s Total Assessment: $195,300
Price: $0 Filed: May 22
724 Ives Street
Seller: Michael J. Delaney, 724 Ives St., Watertown
Buyer: Misty J. Delaney, 724 Ives St., Watertown
Property: built in 1938, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2014 for $136,868
City’s Total Assessment: $167,400
Price: $0 Filed: May 22
205 California Avenue
Seller: Wells Fargo Bank NA
Buyer: Veterans Affairs
Property: built in 1913, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2014 for $130,000
City’s Total Assessment: $102,000
Price: $10 Filed: May 22
205 California Avenue
Seller: David Westbury, Douglas, MA
Buyer: Wells Fargo Bank NA
Property: built in 1913, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2014 for $130,000
City’s Total Assessment: $102,000
Price: $127,571 Filed: May 22
1107 Myrtle Avenue
Seller: Damon R. and Diana D. Trahan, 1107 Myrtle Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Elaine B. Haley, 572 Argent Way, Bluffton, SC
Property: built in 1945, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 1998 for $68,500
City’s Total Assessment: $149,600
Price: $210,000 Filed: May 21
869 and 867 S. Massey Street
Seller: Randy J. Comenole, 869 S. Massey St., Watertown
Buyer: Mikel R. Johnson and Nicole M. Jorge, 36541 Bald Rock Road, Clayton
Property: built in 1930, 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2014 for $94,000
City’s Total Assessment: $80,600
Price: $299,000 Filed: May 21
328 S. Rutland Street
Seller: Sonja E. Rowell, by referee, Zakary Woodruff, Esq., Watertown
Buyer: APN Properties, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., #454, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2018 for $62,500
City’s Total Assessment: $90,100
Price: $50,401 Filed: May 21
133 E. Main Street
Seller: Harrison K. Holdings, LLC, 21700 Farney Pit Road, Carthage
Buyer: Leidy J. Acosta Garzon and Giovanni Sarmiento, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1864, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Dec. 2023 for $55,000
City’s Total Assessment: $70,900
Price: $185,000 Filed: May 21
Prepared by:
117 Scio Street
Seller: Michael Goerger, 45 Church St., Alexandria Bay
Buyer: Jeremy R. Pecori, 114 Scio St., Watertown
Property: vacant lot, sold in July 2002 for $949
City’s Total Assessment: $2,100
Price: $1,000 Filed: May 21
172 Thompson Boulevard
Seller: Michael A. and Kimberly Ferguson, 172 Thompson Blvd., Watertown
Buyer: Paul Pierce and Sarah Compo Pierce, 283 Thompson Blvd., Watertown
Property: built in 1928, 3 bedrooms, 2.6 bathrooms, sold in May 2020 for $265,800
City’s Total Assessment: $228,600
Price: $300,000 Filed: May 21
155 Bishop Street
Seller: Brandon W. and Lauren K. Potter, 155 Bishop St., Watertown
Buyer: Anthony H. Perri and Madison M. Draper, 128 Flower Ave. W., Watertown
Property: built in 1947, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2021 for $210,000
City’s Total Assessment: $165,300
Price: $229,900 Filed: May 20
160 Haven Street
Seller: Northland Operations, LTD, PO Box 674, Brownville, NY
Buyer: Neighbors of Watertown, Inc., 112 Franklin St., Watertown
Property: vacant lot, sold in May 2006 for $1,950
City’s Total Assessment: $1,750
Price: $5,400 Filed: May 20
467 S. Massey Street
Seller: APN Properties, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., #454, Watertown
Buyer: Joseph F. Thomas, 24019 SR 342, Watertown
Property: built in 1924, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Jan. 2024 for $61,850
City’s Total Assessment: $70,500
Price: $175,000 Filed: May 20
173 Ward Street
Seller: Peter and Christine A. Liberatos, 173 Ward St., Watertown
Buyer: Alexis Morris and Peter and Christina Liberatos Life Estate
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $147,700
Price: $0 Filed: May 17
Prepared by:
124 and 132 Willow Street
Seller: Jack Hoff, 124 Willow St., Watertown
Buyer: Jack Hoff, 124 Willow St., Watertown
Price: $0 Filed: May 17
822 Anne Street
Seller: Randy S. Morrow, 822 Anne St., Watertown
Buyer: Anthony J. Chirico Jr., Watertown and Benjamin P. Shoen, Watertown
Property: built in 1908, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2018 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $59,500
Price: $27,500 Filed: May 17
417 Pawling Street
Seller: Benjamin D. Geis and Jessica R. Geis Archer, 417 Pawling St., Watertown
Buyer: Nathaniel L. and Jennifer M. Steelman, 9921-B Saratoga Road, Fort Drum
Property: built in 1893, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in July 2021 for $144,900
City’s Total Assessment: $123,900
Price: $189,900 Filed: May 17
241 W. Main Street
Seller: Elizabeth Stevens, 511-B E. Hoard St., Watertown
Buyer: Randy R. and Shelly A. Fulkerson, 475 Bugbee Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1865, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2013 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $71,400
Price: $73,000 Filed: May 17
540 Stone Street
Seller: Jason C. Stebbins, McIndoe Falls, Vermont
Buyer: Randy R. and Shelly A. Fulkerson, 475 Bugbee Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1970, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2020 for $148,400
City’s Total Assessment: $125,000
Price: $160,000 Filed: May 17
1385 Sherman Street
Seller: David S. Northrop, 40996 County Route 40, Carthage
Buyer: Alexis A. McDermid and Alexander C. Shanahan, 15475 US Route 11, Adams Center
Property: built in 1942, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $113,500
Price: $185,000 Filed: May 16
126 Bishop Street
Seller: Kameron D. Lunde, 126 Bishop St., Watertown
Buyer: Joshua L. and Angela M. Whitworth, Milwaukie, Oregon
Property: built in 1910, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in April 2021 for $181,000
City’s Total Assessment: $148,400
Price: $216,900 Filed: May 16
223 Iroquois Avenue West
Seller: Gregory E. McKinney, executor of Edward P. McKinney Estate
Buyer: Taylor N. McKinney, 25361 E. Gotham Rd., Watertown
Property: built in 1943, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $123,400
Price: $148,700 Filed: May 16
409 East Avenue
Seller: R. Leo Lavarnway III and Barbara Lavarnway, 409 East Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Mark R. Lavarnway, trustee of Lavarnway Family Irrevocable Trust
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $122,800
Price: $0 Filed: May 16
230 Ward Street
Seller: Susan F. McLaughlin, 19803 Collins Landing, Alexandria Bay
Buyer: Martin A. Redder, 230 Ward St., Watertown
Property: built in 1950, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2008 for $125,000
City’s Total Assessment: $103,300
Price: $175,000 Filed: May 16
614 Lillian Street
Seller: Robert K. Pickett and Meghan Robinson by referee Timothy A. Farley, Esq.
Buyer: APN Properties, LLC, 232 Commerce Park Dr., #454, Watertown
Property: built in 1930, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in May 2015 for $62,000
City’s Total Assessment: $71,900
Price: $50,500 Filed: May 15
811 Lawrence Street
Seller: John W.A. Tinsley, III, 9291 Carousel Center, Syracuse
Buyer: Bonnie L. Spencer, Samantha A. Anzalone, and Cordell M. Musselman, Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in March 2006 for $82,000
City’s Total Assessment: $76,500
Price: $180,000 Filed: May 15
1128 Harrison Street
Seller: Barbara Harwood, 1128 Harrison St., Watertown
Buyer: Brigid A. Harwood, 1128 Harrison St., Watertown
Property: built in 1949, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in April 1999 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $104,600
Price: $0 Filed: May 15
708 State Street
Seller: 100 Keys Properties, LLC, 18705 Woodruff Settlement Rd., Watertown
Buyer: Northern Territory, LLC, 912 N. Sandhurst St., Salt Lake City, Utah
Property: built in 1950, sold in July 2021 for $200,000
City’s Total Assessment: $100,200
Price: $357,500 Filed: May 14
176 Duffy Street
Seller: H2O Realty Management, Corp., 1786 New York Ave., North Bellmore, NY
Buyer: NJRE Properties, LLC, 405 Jefferson St., Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $52,900
Price: $135,000 Filed: May 14
537 Eastern Boulevard
Seller: Joshua R. and Brianna L. Woodward, 537 Eastern Blvd., Watertown
Buyer: Travis and Ingrid V. Tiberend, 1215 Superior St., Apt. B12, Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2015 for $150,000
City’s Total Assessment: $109,000
Price: $214,200 Filed: May 13
424 Stone Street
Seller: Laura R. Baughman, 36349 County Route 22, Theresa; Judee Kelly Estate
Buyer: Ashley Hazzard and Breanna Morris-Smith, Stone St., Watertown
Property: built in 1830, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 1996 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $71,600
Price: $108,150 Filed: May 13
855 Superior Street
Seller: Michael J. and Barbara I. Wengler, 2214 Village Center Dr., Encinitias, CA
Buyer: Jason R. and Shawn M. Montondo, 325 Logan St., Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2002 for $47,000
City’s Total Assessment: $65,900
Price: $123,000 Filed: May 13
1032 Bronson St., 1035 Bronson St., 1108 Bronson St., 251 N. Pleasant
Seller: Marceline Bass-Terpstra, 255 N. Pleasant St., Watertown
Buyer: Marceline Bass-Terpstra Living Trust
Price: $0 Filed: May 10
192 Cedar Street
Seller: Northern Credit Union, 121 Factory St., Watertown
Buyer: Aaron Netto, 23997 Gotham St. Road, Watertown
Property: built in 1929, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in April 2022 for $61,403
City’s Total Assessment: $117,000
Price: $27,000 Filed: May 10
170 Haley Street
Seller: Pedro Quinones, 170 Haley St., Watertown
Buyer: Roosevelt Perry, 5000 Owens Way, Apt. 428, Prince George, VA
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2016 for $149,800
City’s Total Assessment: $111,700
Price: $208,000 Filed: May 10
200 Hazelhurst Avenue
Seller: Joseph Gertenschlager, 690 Main St., Watertown
Buyer: 618 James Street, LLC, 636 Stone St., Watertown
Property: sold in Jan. 2009 for $100
City’s Total Assessment: $1,500
Price: $2,000 Filed: May 9
715 Academy Street
Seller: Kathleen M. Freeman, Anita J. Maitland Estate
Buyer: Jason Lyndaker, 116 Phelps St., Watertown
Property: built in 1860, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $75,400
Price: $0 Filed: May 9
1030 Bronson Street
Seller: Renee B. Bittner, Vermont, and Marceline Bass Terpstra, Watertown
Buyer: Marceline Bass Terpstra Living Trust
Property: built in 1950, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $20,200
Price: $0 Filed: May 8
615 LeRay Street
Seller: Ann P. Cousins, 615 LeRay St., Watertown
Buyer: Gerard Shu, 311 James Loop, Killeen, Texas
Property: built in 1890, 6 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 2015 for $95,000
City’s Total Assessment: $81,700
Price: $137,700 Filed: May 8
397 Pawling Street
Seller: Kay E. VanNorton, NYC, administratrix of Douglas W. Stump Estate
Buyer: Kay E. VanNorton, NYC, and The Ruby Maitland Irrevocable Trust
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2006 for $92,200
City’s Total Assessment: $101,000
Price: $207,483 Filed: May 6
259 Barben Avenue
Seller: Jane E. Schofield, 259 Barben Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Cynthia A. Megan, 31 Anthony St., Alexandria Bay
Property: built in 1960, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2000 for $55,000
City’s Total Assessment: $118,500
Price: $124,900 Filed: May 6
712 Emmett Street
Seller: Brian K. and Stacy L. Burgan, 1149 Oak Hollow Dr., Imperial, MO
Buyer: Nicholas Hosmer, 14654 Autumn Ridge Lane, Apt. E., Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2008 for $150,000
City’s Total Assessment: $121,300
Price: $180,000 Filed: May 3
745 Ball Avenue and Rear
Seller: Jack A. Whalen, 745 Ball Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Marsha K. and Harold L. Ferguson Jr.; Ferguson Family Trust, Henderson Harbor
Property: built in 1949, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2021 for $190,000
City’s Total Assessment: $156,000
Price: $239,900 Filed: May 3
402 Stone Street
Seller: Raymond Floyd III and Joni L. Floyd, 1212 Broad St., Leesville, SC
Buyer: Premier Summit, LLC, 351 W. Main St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in June 2012 for $54,500
City’s Total Assessment: $56,500
Price: $26,687 Filed: May 3
510 Dimmick Street
Seller: Revitalized Properties, LLC, PO Box 6046, Watertown
Buyer: Kimberly Spinelli, 14585 Cedar Way, Apt. D, Watertown
Property: built in 1930, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2023 for $130,000
City’s Total Assessment: $95,600
Price: $130,000 Filed: May 2
634 Mundy Street
Seller: Dustin Cobb, 1530 Rusher Dr., Apt. 4A, Alden, NY
Buyer: Gavin M. Burdick and Nichole P. Lent, 678 Cooper St., Apt. 1, Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 2018 for $124,000
City’s Total Assessment: $112,500
Price: $158,100 Filed: May 2
671 Grant Street
Seller: Christopher Chin by referee Andrew N. Capone, Esq.
Buyer: William R. George, 22101 Fabco Road, Suite 5, Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2012 for $129,900
City’s Total Assessment: $107,600
Price: $77,000 Filed: May 2
421 S. Massey Street
Seller: Hammer PA, LLC, Elkins Park, PA
Buyer: Date O. Dakitse, 421 S. Massey St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2023 for $70,000
City’s Total Assessment: $83,000
Price: $233,094 Filed: May 2
367 Brainard Street
Seller: Linya H. Bell, 106 Brady Rd., Sackets Harbor
Buyer: NNY REI, LLC, and Legacy Home Stays, LLC, Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Feb. 1994 for $50,000
City’s Total Assessment: $101,100
Price: $70,000 Filed: May 2
107 N. Orchard Street
Seller: Pink Palace Properties, Cape Coral, FL
Buyer: Jacob F. Benninger, 433 Newman Dr., Watertown
Property: built in 1950, sold in Jan. 2022 for $137,000
City’s Total Assessment: $74,800
Price: $239,900 Filed: May 2
552 LeRay Street
Seller: Gerardo Diaz, 122 Stuart St., Watertown
Buyer: Sunrise Horizons, LLC, 36403 Nolan Road, Theresa
Property: built in 1895, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in May 2020 for $14,500
City’s Total Assessment: $64,900
Price: $47,000 Filed: May 1
406 Stone Street
Seller: Nationstar Mortgage, LLC, Coppell, Texas
Buyer: Pervez Hai, 1091 Pfingsten Rd., Northbrook, IL
Property: built in 1870, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2023 for $97,381
City’s Total Assessment: $79,500
Price: $24,000 Filed: May 1
714 LeRay Street
Seller: Paul M. Nicol, 714 LeRay St., Watertown
Buyer: Derek and Susy Bongard, Inverary, Ontario
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2016 for $110,050
City’s Total Assessment: $66,200
Price: $120,000 Filed: May 1