WATERTOWN, N.Y. — The latest property transactions in the city of Watertown filed at the Jefferson County clerk’s office in May 2025:
Looking to buy or sell property in Jefferson County?
616 Coffeen Street
Seller: Capone Coffeen, LLC, 1040 Del Haven Dr., Delray, Florida
Buyer: Capone Family, LLC, 1040 Del Haven Dr., Delray, Florida
Property: built in 1959, commercial building, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $642,300
Price: $0 Filed: May 30
406 Stone Street
Seller: Hai Pervez, 1091 Pfingsten Road, Northbrook, IL
Buyer: True Vision Homes, LLC, 17802 N. Adams Heights, Adams
Property: built in 1870, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold April 2024 for $24,000
City’s Total Assessment: $79,500
Price: $50,000 Filed: May 30
273 and 265 Bellew Avenue
Seller: Michael L. Puccia, John J. Puccia, James J. Puccia, David G. Puccia, Diane S. Puccia
Buyer: Noah J. Murrock, 21687 Redwood Lane, Apt. B, Watertown
Price: $250,000 Filed: May 29
1635 Olmsted Drive
Seller: Robert J. Simmons, 1390 Charleston St., Kings George, VA
Buyer: Thomas W. Besch and Adriana M. Besch, Lawton, OK
Property: built in 1959, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold July 2022 for $205,000
City’s Total Assessment: $158,200
Price: $237,500 Filed: May 28
555 LeRay Street
Seller: Susan T. McVeigh trustee of R. Taube Family Trust
Buyer: Susan T. McVeigh, Michael A. Taube Special Needs Trust
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Aug. 2020 for $55,000
City’s Total Assessment: $63,600
Price: $1 Filed: May 28
638 Mundy Street
Seller: Dennis McKenna, 638 Mundy St., Watertown, executor of John J. Reagan Jr. Estate
Buyer: Revitalized Properties, LLC, 228 Ten Eyck St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Jan. 2005 for $43,000
City’s Total Assessment: $52,500
Price: $25,000 Filed: May 27
254 Breen Avenue
Seller: James W. Ranger and Therese M. Ranger, 254 Breen Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Alyson L. Ranger, Watertown, and Zachary D. Ranger, Raleigh, NC
Property: built in 1890, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Nov. 1999 for $10
City’s Total Assessment: $78,100
Price: $0 Filed: May 23
438 East Avenue
Seller: Joan L. Allen Estate, David R. Allen, Watertown
Buyer: David R. Allen and Betty J. Allen, 438 East Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1925, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $87,900
Price: $0 Filed: May 22
846 Emmett Street
Seller: Aaron Netto, 32997 CR 159, Watertown
Buyer: Sand Flats Mgmt, LLC, 846 Emmett St., Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold July 2017 for $35,450
City’s Total Assessment: $123,900
Price: $150,000 Filed: May 22
148 N. Meadow Street
Seller: Douglas Ward by his attorney in fact, Cynthia L. Spooner, Watertown
Buyer: Cynthia L. Spooner, 25241 SR 180, Dexter
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Aug. 2020 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $83,600
Price: $0 Filed: May 22
136 Court Street
Seller: 5G Real Estate Group, LLC, Cochran Road, Pittsburgh, PA
Buyer: 136 Apple, LLC, Cochran Road, Pittsburgh, PA
Property: built in 1950, commercial building, sold June 2024 for $145,000
City’s Total Assessment: $84,300
Price: $0 Filed: May 20
1018 Academy Street
Seller: Tom J. Batchlear and Inkyoung Seok, Aurora, Colorado
Buyer: Ruth-Ellen Van Arnam and John S. Van Arnam, 27635 Chisholm Trail, Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold Oct. 2011 for $161,000
City’s Total Assessment: $137,600
Price: $200,000 Filed: May 19
1013 Salina Street
Seller: Kate D. Harrienger and Michael Harrienger, 24287 CR 67, Watertown
Buyer: 1013 Salina Street, LLC, PO Box 116, Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold Nov. 2019 for $90,000
City’s Total Assessment: $105,400
Price: $1 Filed: May 16
513 Hamlin Street
Seller: Kate D. Harrienger and Michael Harrienger, 24287 CR 67, Watertown
Buyer: 513 Hamlin Street, LLC, PO Box 116, Watertown
Property: built in 1902, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold Aug. 2022 for $95,000
City’s Total Assessment: $93,300
Price: $1 Filed: May 16
918 Academy Street
Seller: Scott D. Thomas, Liverpool, NY, and Misty Ann Thomas, Chester, VA
Buyer: 918 Ymedaca Street, LLC, PO Box 116, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold July 2004 for $61,850
City’s Total Assessment: $11,800
Price: $44,000 Filed: May 16
679 Grant Street
Seller: Karen K. Reid, Sackets Harbor, Timothy W. Keller Estate
Buyer: Monument Property Group, LLC, 339 Dodge Ave., Sackets Harbor
Property: built in 1888, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Aug. 2008 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $67,100
Price: $40,000 Filed: May 15
605 Hamilton Street
Seller: Kate D. Harrienger and Michael Harrienger, 24287 CR 67, Watertown
Buyer: 605 Hamilton St. S, LLC, PO Box 116, Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold July 2021 for $615
City’s Total Assessment: $62,100
Price: $1 Filed: May 15
740 Knickerbocker Drive
Seller: Kristina McFarlane and Jesse McFarlane, 740 Knickerbocker Dr., Watertown
Buyer: Mollie E. Guyette, 273 W. Flower Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1945, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold Aug. 2023 for $227,000
City’s Total Assessment: $162,800
Price: $240,000 Filed: May 15
659 Flower Street
Seller: Ricky U. Vaca and Shelby L. Vaca, Fort Huachuca, AZ
Buyer: Gregory Van Orden, 302 Rutland St., Watertown
Property: built in 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Aug. 2017 for $78,000
City’s Total Assessment: $65,100
Price: $130,000 Filed: May 15
613 Washington Street
Seller: Cascade Funding Mortgage Trust HB 11, 14405 Walters Rd., Houston, TX
Buyer: EMERHS, LLC, 209 Lake Ave., Lyndhurst, NJ
Property: built in 1880, 8 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold July 2024 for $181,495
City’s Total Assessment: $108,800
Price: $28,000 Filed: May 14
VL 1 Bellew Avenue
Seller: Arbel, LLC, 137 Main Ave., Floor 3, Watertown
Buyer: Americu Credit Union, 1916 Black River Blvd., Rome
Property: vacant lot, sold Aug. 2014 for $18,000
City’s Total Assessment: $8,000
Price: $45,000 Filed: May 14
1523 Columbia Street
Seller: Timothy D. Comer, 1523 Columbia St., Watertown
Buyer: Brett and Melissa Acevedo, 1429 Gill St., Watertown
Property: built in 1965, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Nov. 2021 for $170,000
City’s Total Assessment: $148,000
Price: $255,500 Filed: May 13
254 Bellew Avenue
Seller: Gloria T. Schweinsberg, 254 Bellew Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Michael Nachison, 250 Bellew Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1950, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $116,050
Price: $145,000 Filed: May 13
1208 Gill Street
Seller: Brandi S. Groman by referee Zakary Wodruff, Esq.
Buyer: Community Bank NA, Olean, NY
Property: built in 1925, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold July 2008 for $35,000
City’s Total Assessment: $79,500
Price: $72,533 Filed: May 12
159 Mullin Street
Seller: Urban Nature Spa and Salon, Inc., 159 Mullin St., Watertown
Buyer: Mazer Industries, LLC, 258835 Contessa Lane, Watertown
Property: built in 1950, sold Sept. 2020 for $175,000
City’s Total Assessment: $168,100
Price: $280,000 Filed: May 12
216 N. Indiana Avenue
Seller: Michelle J Mourino, 216 N. Indiana Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Colten Denver Bargo, Lakewood, WA
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Sept. 2021 for $154,000
City’s Total Assessment: $124,800
Price: $187,000 Filed: May 12
Prepared by:
651 Cooper Street
Seller: Joey W. Dunn and Kari L. Dunn, Rineyville, KY
Buyer: Howard J. Simpson, 250 State St., Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Sept. 2005 for $85,000
City’s Total Assessment: $93,600
Price: $132,000 Filed: May 12
Prepared by:
111 N. Indiana Avenue
Seller: Claro Garcia and Maria Garcia, Fort Cavazos, Texas
Buyer: Garcia Family Trust, Fort Cavazos, Texas
Property: built in 1925, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold March 2023 for $190,800
City’s Total Assessment: $142,200
Price: $1 Filed: May 12
345 Colorado Avenue North
Seller: Michael J. Grandjean, 24920 Ridge Road, Watertown
Buyer: Ethan I. Richards, 14772 Autumn Ridge Lane, Watertown
Property: built in 1920, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Jan. 2007 for $83,100
City’s Total Assessment: $96,300
Price: $174,900 Filed: May 9
315 S. Indiana Avenue
Seller: Matthew J. MacVittie and Katharine A. St. Laurent, Oswego
Buyer: Mikel Miller and Felicia Miller, Fort Drum
Property: built in 1930, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold March 2022 for $165,000
City’s Total Assessment: $141,500
Price: $225,000 Filed: May 8
1641 Columbia Street
Seller: Carrie Foster, 1641 Columbia St., Watertown
Buyer: Taylor Kraka, 1641 Columbia St., Watertown
Property: built in 1950, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold June 2022 for $193,000
City’s Total Assessment: $143,500
Price: $224,000 Filed: May 8
157 and 159 Mechanic Street
Seller: Shannon Rexford, Clayton, and Timothy Rexford, Watertown
Buyer: Barbosa Real Estate, LLC, Perch Lake Road, Watertown
Property: built in 1880, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Nov. 2016 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $79,500
Price: $72,000 Filed: May 7
308 Park Drive
Seller: Christopher M. Hutchison-Vaughn, 308 Park Dr. W., Watertown
Buyer: William Marx, 407 Simpson St., Hinesville, GA
Property: built in 1920, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold Dec. 2021 for $145,000
City’s Total Assessment: $121,600
Price: $217,194 Filed: May 7
1208 Harris Drive
Seller: Dustin R. and Jacquelyn K. Ferguson, Spring Lake, NC
Buyer: Andrew J. and Brooke J. Boulter, 153 Barben Ave., Watertown
Property: built in 1965, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold Aug. 2017 for $222,200
City’s Total Assessment: $211,600
Price: $285,000 Filed: May 6
320 Paddock Street
Seller: Alfred L. and Jean C. Gianfagna, 320 Paddock St., Watertown
Buyer: Andrew I. Gianfagna, Saranac Lake, Anthony J. Gianfagna, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1937, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $284,300
Price: $0 Filed: May 5
1543 State Street
Seller: Gala Farms, LLC, 23997 Gotham St., Watertown
Buyer: Expert Properties, LLC, 351 Whipple Road, Bernhards Bay
Property: built in 1970, commercial building, sold Nov. 2016 for $25,600
City’s Total Assessment: $63,700
Price: $320,000 Filed: May 5
196 Ely Street
Seller: Secretary of Housing and Urban Development
Buyer: Alldunn Enterprises, LLC, 23445 Clark Dr., Dexter
Property: built in 1881, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold Dec. 2024 for $10
City’s Total Assessment: $88,900
Price: $47,500 Filed: May 5
Part of 121 / 117 Haney Street
Seller: Janette M. Orto, 117 Haney St., Watertown
Buyer: Calcium Properties, LLC, 1222 Arsenal St., Suite 14, Watertown
Price: $1 Filed: May 1
1158 State Street
Seller: James D. and Janice M. Norris, 2541 Alexandra Meadows, Watertown
Buyer: Megan Lopez and Christopher Cangelosi, 947 Summer St., Watertown
Property: built in 1905, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $144,200
Price: $249,900 Filed: May 1
123 N. Pleasant Street
Seller: James C. Gaddy, 123 N. Pleasant St., Watertown
Buyer: Kimbermarie Murphy, 414 Franklin St., Watertown
Property: built in 1890, 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold March 2022 for $140,000
City’s Total Assessment: $94,100
Price: $165,000 Filed: May 1