WATERTOWN, N.Y. — The latest property transactions in the city of Watertown filed at the Jefferson County clerk’s office in September 2025:
Looking to buy or sell property in Jefferson County?
217 Arsenal Street
Seller: 217 Arsenal Street, LLC, 1080 Pittsford Victor Rd., Suite 300, Pittsford
Buyer: County of Jefferson, 195 Arsenal St., Watertown
Property: built in 1906, commercial building, sold in June 2013 for $185,000
City’s Total Assessment: $120,000
Price: $500,000 Filed: September 30
353 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Nancy L. Scott, Raymondville
Buyer: Emily Eibert, 26125 Harrier Court, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1885, 5 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $121,800
Price: $1 Filed: September 30
271 Elm Street
Seller: MacLean P. Barnes and Fiona N. Barnes, 271 Elm St., Watertown
Buyer: Robert L. Kiernan and Robin A. Kiernan, 20549 Weaver Rd., Watertown
Property: built in 1960, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 2022 for $241,000
City’s Total Assessment: $204,300
Price: $295,000 Filed: September 30
1102 Franklin Street
Seller: Thomas D. Majo, 420 Moffett St., Watertown
Buyer: Joseph M. Majo, Brooklyn, Jessica Majo, Dexter, Thomas D. Majo Irrevocable Trust
Property: built in 1850, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2017 for $50,000
City’s Total Assessment: $87,900
Price: $0 Filed: September 29
420 Moffett Street
Seller: Thomas D. Majo, 420 Moffett St., Watertown
Buyer: Joseph M. Majo, Brooklyn, Jessica Majo, Dexter, Thomas D. Majo Irrevocable Trust
Property: built in 1830, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 1995 for $22,000
City’s Total Assessment: $89,000
Price: $0 Filed: September 29
1120 Temple Street
Seller: James P. Graham, 1120 Temple St., Watertown
Buyer: Slainte Holdings, LLC, 1120 Temple St., Watertown
Property: built in 1956, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2023 for $220,000
City’s Total Assessment: $142,800
Price: $0 Filed: September 26
330 Brainard Street
Seller: Darren T. Porter, 24991 Bonney Road, Watertown
Buyer: T. Brooks & Associates, LLC, 327 Mullin St., Watertown
Property: built in 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in April 2009 for $70,000
City’s Total Assessment: $72,100
Price: $0 Filed: September 26
414 S. Pleasant Street
Seller: Marion E. Morrison Living Trust
Buyer: Robert W. and Jennifer F. Briscoe, Broadway Ave. W., Watertown
Property: built in 1924, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2014 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $110,100
Price: $200,000 Filed: September 26
212 W. Iroquois Avenue
Seller: Jill L. Parker, Brownville, and Michael D. Hodkinson, Brantingham
Buyer: Aleksandre Jolia, 26333 Lanner Lane, Evans Mills
Property: built in 1942, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 200 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $115,400
Price: $250,000 Filed: September 26
12 Starbuck Avenue
Seller: John Cleary, 259 E. Main St., Watertown
Buyer: Susan M. O’Leary, 235 E. Hoard St., Watertown
Property: vacant land, sold in Aug. 2024 for $112
City’s Total Assessment: $5,450
Price: $5,000 Filed: September 25
230 Franklin Street
Seller: The Franklin Factory Group, LLC, 200 Washington St., Watertown
Buyer: Expert Properties, LLC, 351 Whipple Rd., Berhards Bay, NY
Property: built 1968, commercial building, sold in Jan. 2004 for $85,000
City’s Total Assessment: $178,000
Price: $200,000 Filed: September 25
124 Smith Street
Seller: Wilson K. Valentin and Jessica A. Valentin, 124 Smith St., Watertown
Buyer: Jessica A. Valentin, 124 Smith St., Watertown
Property: built 1880, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in March 2024 for $244,900
City’s Total Assessment: $93,100
Price: $0 Filed: September 25
583 West Prospect Street
Seller: Patricia C. Spaziani, 583 W. Prospect St., Watertown
Buyer: William O. Monica, 146 Keyes Ave., Watertown
Property: built 1900, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $64,900
Price: $0 Filed: September 25
717 Water Street
Seller: Kenneth D. Roney, Jr., Beverly Hills, FL
Buyer: Sherry E. Roney, 717 Water St., Watertown
Property: built 1890, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2019 for $94,250
City’s Total Assessment: $118,700
Price: $0 Filed: September 25
237 Michigan Avenue
Seller: Nathaniel B. Mullen and Haley A. Kuehn, 237 Michigan Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Patrick Hodge, 25253 E. Gotham Road, Watertown
Property: built 1932, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Dec. 2023 for $183,000
City’s Total Assessment: $110,800
Price: $225,000 Filed: September 24
235 Ward Street
Seller: Rose M. LaFountain, Mark LaFountain, Syracuse, Stephanie Bennett, Irmo, SC, and Sean LaFountain, Las Vegas, NV
Buyer: Jacob M. Edgar, 45 Henry St., Westerly, RI
Property: built 1952, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Dec. 2013 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $96,400
Price: $210,000 Filed: September 23
316 S. Meadow Street
Seller: Reyna M. Chavez Hernandez, 1232 Kings Road, Palmdale, CA
Buyer: Dylan R. and McKayla K. McLeod, 339 Jackson Ave., Bradford, PA
Property: built 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in May 2021 for $116,500
City’s Total Assessment: $101,800
Price: $165,000 Filed: September 23
1031 Sherman Street
Seller: Kathleen A. and James P. Finnerty, 1031 Sherman St., Watertown
Buyer: Timothy P. Mattiace and Brianne E. Mattiace, 418 Harris Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1951, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2014 for $80,000
City’s Total Assessment: $133,300
Price: $252,900 Filed: September 22
943 Gotham Street
Seller: Douglas W. and Joann Stevens, Ocala, FL
Buyer: Eric P. Soper and Caren J. Legislador Beboso, 317 Academy St., Watertown
Property: built 1900, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2000 for $40,000
City’s Total Assessment: $93,300
Price: $165,000 Filed: September 22
1138 Harrison Street
Seller: Peter A. and Amy L. Schwerzmann, 36857 Rock Beach Road W., Clayton
Buyer: Zackary Velasquez, 1138 Harrison St., Watertown
Property: built 1940, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $169,300
Price: $282,500 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
147 Park Avenue and 147 Rear Park Avenue
Seller: Victor M. Evans and Morgan A. Evans, Grovetown, GA
Buyer: Nadia T. Horn and Adrian Garib, 830 Davidson St., Watertown
Property: built 1893, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Sept. 2021 for $199,500
City’s Total Assessment: $170,100
Price: $265,000 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
416 Gotham Street
Seller: Hervey Lorjuste and Esther L. Lorjuste, 416 Gotham St., Watertown
Buyer: Tanica Joseph, 416 Gotham St., Watertown
Property: built 1920, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2007 for $84,750
City’s Total Assessment: $83,800
Price: $175,000 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
717 Lawrence Street
Seller: Sally J. Fay, Heber City, UT, and Brenton E. Reinhardt, Bozeman, MT
Buyer: Cameron and Abigail D. Hicks, Butler Loop, Watertown
Property: built 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in May 2024 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $99,700
Price: $180,000 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
706 Lawrence Street
Seller: Matthew White, 706 Lawrence St., Watertown
Buyer: Christine Munger, 706 Lawrence St., Watertown
Property: built 1880, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Dec. 2020 for $102,000
City’s Total Assessment: $83,400
Price: $205,000 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
706 Lawrence Street
Seller: Matthew White, 706 Lawrence St., Watertown
Buyer: Christine Munger, 706 Lawrence St., Watertown
Property: built 1880, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Dec. 2020 for $102,000
City’s Total Assessment: $83,400
Price: $205,000 Filed: September 22
Prepared by:
764 Mill Street
Seller: Theodore S. Randall Estate by executor, Lori Randall, 146 Winthrop St., Watertown
Buyer: Lori Randall, 146 Winthrop St., Watertown
Property: built 1917, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in July 2011 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $59,900
Price: $0 Filed: September 22
360 Brainard Street
Seller: Navy Federal Credit Union, Vienna, VA
Buyer: Veterans Affairs, Nashville, TN
Property: built 1880, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2025 for $256,989
City’s Total Assessment: $172,400
Price: $1 Filed: September 22
523 Arsenal Street
Seller: Khatoon, LLC, 523 Arsenal St., Watertown
Buyer: Rubina Khatoon, 949 Kieff Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1880, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2024 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: n/a
Price: $1 Filed: September 18
1102 Salina Street
Seller: Diana Nugent-Ward and Joanne Nugent-Ward, 156 Chestnut St., Watertown
Buyer: Clifford Lashway, 235 Pratt St., Watertown
Property: built 1906, 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2001 for $59,500
City’s Total Assessment: $105,400
Price: $85,000 Filed: September 18
223 Keyes Avenue
Seller: Troy D. Busby and Dena L. Busby, Center Harbor, NH
Buyer: Michael Pierson, 23791 Forest Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1889, sold in April 2007 for $185,000
City’s Total Assessment: $187,800
Price: $230,000 Filed: September 17
531 S. Massey Street
Seller: Corey I. Cuppernell, 531 S. Massey St., Watertown
Buyer: Joshua A. Tanner, 120 Keyes Ave., Watertown
Property: built 1920, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Feb. 2019 for $75,000
City’s Total Assessment: $78,700
Price: $137,900 Filed: September 15
618 Holcomb Street
Seller: Vanduzee Street Properties, 142 Arcade St., Suite 101, Watertown
Buyer: Calb C. Atkins and Ana M. Atkins Mateo, 15614 Eimicke Place, Apt. 401, Watertown
Property: built 1925, 6 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, sold in March 2025 for $150,000
City’s Total Assessment: $226,600
Price: $345,000 Filed: September 15
111 S. Hamilton Street
Seller: Americu Credit Union, 1916 Black River Blvd., Rome
Buyer: Honey Bee Properties NNY, LLC, c/o Molly E. Hall, 1634 State St., Watertown
Property: built 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Aug. 2024 for $144,900
City’s Total Assessment: $123,000
Price: $85,000 Filed: September 15
516 Dimmick Street
Seller: Laura M. Porter, 516 Dimmick St., Watertown
Buyer: Noah P. Dutton, 497 Newell St., Apt. 218, Watertown
Property: built 1930, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in June 2017 for $138,000
City’s Total Assessment: $121,300
Price: $185,000 Filed: September 15
168 Sterling Street
Seller: NC Estates, LLC, 229 Clinton St., Watertown
Buyer: Kamiya Real Estate, LLC, 23255 Diane Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1960, apartment building, sold in Sept. 2021 for $216,900
City’s Total Assessment: $139,400
Price: $213,480 Filed: September 15
1137 Franklin Street
Seller: Chet Sulek, 2515 Barbara Lane, Cumming, GA
Buyer: Chelsey Patch, 146 Ten Eyck St., Apt. 2, Watertown
Property: built 1920, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2016 for $65,000
City’s Total Assessment: $81,100
Price: $110,000 Filed: September 12
132-138 St. Mary Street
Seller: US Bank Trust National Association
Buyer: Myron C. Kehoe Jr., 1115 Gotham St., Watertown
Property: built 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2024 for $60,792
City’s Total Assessment: $64,300
Price: $35,000 Filed: September 12
242 Paddock Street
Seller: Charles E. Bates and Lynne M. Bates, 252, Paddock St., Watertown
Buyer: Jay Thompson and Keri Thompson, 21259 Wrape Rd., Carthage
Property: built 1900, 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2008 for $275,000
City’s Total Assessment: $292,900
Price: $450,000 Filed: September 12
230 N. Indiana Avenue
Seller: John J. Reagan, Jr., Estate, by executor Dennis McKenna
Buyer: Micheal Saunders, American Fork, VT
Property: built 1910, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Sept. 2018 for $0
City’s Total Assessment: $96,800
Price: $175,000 Filed: September 12
507 W. Mullin Street
Seller: Daniel J. Toper, 507 W. Mullin St., Watertown
Buyer: John Toper, Clayton, and Jennifer Toper-Gaines, Roanoke, VA
Property: built 1890, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $48,100
Price: $1 Filed: September 11
507 W. Mullin Street
Seller: Daniel J. and Mona L. Toper, 507 W. Mullin St., Watertown
Buyer: Daniel J. Toper, 507 W. Mullin St., Watertown
Property: built 1890, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in n/a
City’s Total Assessment: $48,100
Price: $1 Filed: September 11
428 Prospect Street
Seller: Selene Nguyen, 428 Prospect St., Watertown
Buyer: North Star Rentals NNY, LLC, 1634 State St., Watertown
Property: built 1895, 2 bedrooms, 1.5 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2019 for $80,392
City’s Total Assessment: $53,100
Price: $55,000 Filed: September 11
312 W. Iroquois Avenue
Seller: Patrick L. and Linda R. McNutt, Raleigh, NC
Buyer: Alexia Hsu, 214 Creekside Lane, Sackets Harbor
Property: built 1942, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Oct. 2006 for $80,000
City’s Total Assessment: $95,000
Price: $250,000 Filed: September 10
216 St. Mary Street
Seller: Mikesael Nieves, Haverhill, Mass.
Buyer: Marie Sain Val Divers, 216 St. Mary St., Watertown
Property: built 1905, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Aug. 2021 for $120,000
City’s Total Assessment: $84,500
Price: $130,000 Filed: September 10
146 Seymour Street
Seller: Joshua Cummings, 11206 Lowe Road, Rodman
Buyer: Shawn Delello, 146 Seymour St., Watertown
Property: built 1917, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Jan. 2018 for $69,500
City’s Total Assessment: $74,100
Price: $162,000 Filed: September 9
Prepared by:
416 Pawling Street
Seller: William George, 22101 Fabco Road, Suite 5, Watertown
Buyer: Megan Basenfelder, 1019 State St., Watertown
Property: built 1890, 4 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Feb. 2025 for $78,100
City’s Total Assessment: $101,900
Price: $213,000 Filed: September 9
319 Flower Avenue East
Seller: Americu Credit Union, 1916 Black River Blvd., Rome
Buyer: Kanokphan Woolcott, 19725 Hillside Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1893, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Jan. 2025 for $1,000
City’s Total Assessment: $70,000
Price: $92,019 Filed: September 8
126 Moore Avenue
Seller: Cyrus J. Beckman, 126 Moore Ave., Watertown
Buyer: Marc Riley, 9102 Grimsland, San Antonio, TX
Property: built 1926, 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2019 for $160,000
City’s Total Assessment: $123,000
Price: $215,000 Filed: September 8
169 Haley Street
Seller: Tyler A. Inhofe, 169 Haley St., Watertown
Buyer: Evan Morine, 22272 Patricia Dr., Watertown
Property: built 1925, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2021 for $196,000
City’s Total Assessment: $166,700
Price: $245,000 Filed: September 5
1141 State Street
Seller: Castlerock 2023, LLC, 120 Bloomingdale Rd., White Plains, NY
Buyer: North Star Rentals, LLC, 1634 State St., Watertown
Property: built 1920, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2024 for $50,500
City’s Total Assessment: $95,700
Price: $69,300 Filed: September 4
115 S. Pleasant Street
Seller: Alliance Properties of New York, LLC, 115 S. Pleasant St., Watertown
Buyer: Lawrence W. Danza and Kil-Cha Danza, 115 S. Pleasant St., Watertown
Property: built 1970, 4 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Dec. 2013 for $1
City’s Total Assessment: $100,200
Price: $0 Filed: September 4
1357 Ives Street
Seller: Matthew C. Plumpton, 1357 Ives St., Watertown
Buyer: Nicholas E. Hosmer, 712 Emmett St., Watertown
Property: built 1970, 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in March 2019 for $120,000
City’s Total Assessment: $153,200
Price: $269,900 Filed: September 4
714 Ball Avenue
Seller: Mary M. Kirch, 38 Georgetown Lane, Fairport, NY
Buyer: Joel Kanyinda, 26852 Anable Ave., Evans Mills
Property: built 1934, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, sold in April 1994 for $89,500
City’s Total Assessment: $185,600
Price: $352,000 Filed: September 4
112 S. Pleasant Street
Seller: Verne M. Edward, Yuma, AZ
Buyer: Zachary Methven, 613 Sherman St., Watertown
Property: built 1925, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in March 2022 for $96,000
City’s Total Assessment: $80,800
Price: $152,000 Filed: September 3
747 Coffeen Street
Seller: Jie He and Chen Jiang, 16955 County Route 59, Dexter
Buyer: Austin Montgomery, 117 California Ave., Watertown
Property: built 1900, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in Nov. 2019 for $147,500
City’s Total Assessment: $99,700
Price: $189,000 Filed: September 3
700 Lansing Street
Seller: Erasmo F. Cujilema, 700 Lansing St., Watertown
Buyer: Scott M. Colony and Jennifer S. Pound, 105 Wendell Lane, Black River
Property: built 1910, 3 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, sold in Oct. 2021 for $158,000
City’s Total Assessment: $120,000
Price: $162,500 Filed: September 2
227 Elm Street
Seller: Thomas G. and Judy P. Compo, 227 Elm St., Watertown
Buyer: Rebecca E. Buchanan, 17 Moreland Ave., Albany
Property: built 1959, 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, sold in Nov. 2022 for $188,000
City’s Total Assessment: $153,700
Price: $289,000 Filed: September 2
360 Brainard Street
Seller: Colton A. Campbell, 360 Brainard St., Watertown
Buyer: Navy Federal Credit Union, Vienna, VA
Property: built 1880, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, sold in June 2023 for $239,900
City’s Total Assessment: $172,400
Price: $256,989 Filed: September 2